Best Book Critics

The best book critics

Part of our efforts to uncover the rest of the best, we contacted the judges to ask what they voted for and why. Michiko Kakutani's Literature Life: The Best Feudations and Critical Reviewers | Bücher

The New York Times' honored New York Times critics, Michiko Kakutani, said she will be resigning from her position on Thursday after 38 years, ending a remarkable and fearful life in the heart of the authors whose works she has review. He was America's most influential literature reviewer, exerting an enormous impact on the professional lives of aspiring and incumbent authors at the same time.

Kakutani was treated with remarkable caution during her Times term, making few performances in publics and letting her review speaks for itself. As a tribute to such a acclaimed reviewer - the writer behind the plays who began the career of David Foster-Wallace, George Saunders and Zadie Smith and enraged many others - their best feuding and reviewing has collapsed here.

While Kakutani commended Jonathan Franzens novel The Corrections as a "devastating famil portrayal and a shocking portrayal of America in the latter 1990s," he was less fascinated by his 2006 memoirs The Discomfort Zone and asked "why anyone would be interested in pages and pages about this unfortunate affair or the self-important and self-promoting content of Mr. Franzens spirit.

Then two years later, in a conversation with James Wood at Harvard, he increased the stakes by calling the reviewer "the dumbest figure in New York City. It is fifteen years since Kakutani said that "it is not possible for the readers to find a credible figure " in John Updike's Seeek My Face, a novel à cif inspired by the life of Jackson Pollack and Lee Krasner.

To be on the safe side, she added that the book seemed to be penned "by a rotten, voyeuristic and reducing hand". In response to the request, Updike told a journalist that he was largely unharmed by "professional reviewer like Michiko Kakutani, who works on so many works that there is a hidden hate for all the works that go through, or a desire to dismiss".

Kakutani praised the writer for his extensive, post-modern story about the Berglund dynasty when the end result came in the shape of his extensive novel Freedom: While Kakutani was instrumental in starting Zadie Smith's carreer after reading her first novel, White Teeth, it is her appreciation of Smith's On Beauty that really puts her greatest presents as a reviewer into the prose:

Few critics had anything to say about the underworld when it first appeared in 1997, including Kakutani. She praised Delillo in her reviews and found a seamless way to record the words "Effluvia". "DeLillo wrote this book with his amazing new novel, or at least an approach to it.

When the aim of a good book report is to encourage the readers to buy the book themselves, Kakutani was unique in taking a real work of artwork - Toni Morrison's lover, for example - and reviewing it almost as pointedly and skilfully as the books she was thinking about:

Like most Kakutani was an avid fan of Junot Diaz's 2007 novel The Brief, Wonderrous Life of Oscar Wao, but her reviews of his story collections, This is How You Loose Her, gave intelligent insight into the way his innate talents for characterisation have been transformed into a smaller, less Romance dimension:

Kakutani's 2004 critique of the former president's memoirs continues to be a collision course in the arts of fiction takedowns and a vivid testimony to the critic's often radiant sincerity. "This book, which has more than 950 pages, is slovenly narcissistic and often boring with a wink - the tone of a man chatting away, not for the readers, but for himself and a remote receptionist of the story.

A Murakami sceptic, Kakutani wrote warm summaries of his other works such as After the Quake and Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and His Years of Pilgrimage. Kakutani was a consistent Murakami sceptic. The Kakutani's criticism was as concise in non-fiction as iniction. Your critique of Henry Kissinger's On China, a compilation of the former foreign minister's reflections on a land he was well acquainted with, shows Kakutani's talent for editing through political language:

For the book Kakutani reserved some of her hardest critiques:...we have a small favor to ask. This is what distinguishes us from so many others in the press at a times when objective, truthful coverage is crucial.

Mehr zum Thema